Not a word for the possible environmental impact of plummeting mosquito populations, an insect which many animals (bats, etc) heavily prey on? Even more so as the Oxitec tech has the potential to make this decline irreversible
I was also looking for this in the article. I have no prior opinions, but are there tradeoffs with regard to reducing the mosquito population? It seems pretty glib to use the "you can just do stuff" framing and not spend a little time with tradeoffs, or if that's not a concern then explain why.
Easy to sit in developed countries and muse about ‘environmental impacts’. If our friends and neighbors were dying of malaria would we be so concerned about hypotheticals and by consequence so indifferent to the plight of millions? Suppose we somehow eradicate mosquitos in a few areas and find that the consequences are unexpectedly disastrous, well we can always let them come back, can’t we? Worldwide eradication, even with a broad consensus and massive funding would take decades—if mosquito eradication leads to bad consequences we’ll be able to see them unfold in slow-motion and change course. Lastly, it’s worth noting that many of these mosquitos are invasive species, and so this effort could be viewed correctly as restoring natural systems to an earlier state.
I could roll with such a plan, with a few extra precautions (think about the consequences of potential horizontal gene transfers, etc). My point was : when you write such an article, show me that you have thought about biodiversity and have a serious plan in this respect
I was also missing a bit of nuance in the article beyond simply implying that faster approval is automatically better. Perhaps the environmental risks are extremely low compared to public health benefits, but they do bring a new kind of uncertainty that should be discussed.
Regulatory caution makes sense given this uncertainty. At the same time, delays cost lives, so it’s troubling if they happen because agencies struggle to decide whether an engineered mosquito is a “drug” or a “pesticide”.
Humans need to stop messing with nature and find natural solutions to the problems we face. I’m no tree hugger, but eradicating an entire species will certainly have devastating downstream ecological consequences. We are not gods and we need to stop acting like we are.
I agree, but to not address the likely tradeoffs seems like a bit of an omission in an article by WiP. I enjoy their work and usually find them rigorous and persuasive. There might be good reasons not to worry, or to accept the tradeoffs and deploy the technology for the human health benefits. I just want to see that in the article.
Caution regarding ecological cascades is warranted, yet treating the status quo as morally neutral ignores millions of preventable deaths. Specific mosquito vectors occupy narrow niches where targeted removal carries low ecological risk.
How do you know it will have devastating downstream consequences? Will they be worse than the consequences of allowing these animals infect and kill many millions of humans every year?
Obviously I'm not saying this because of my sentimentalism and love for mosquitoes. In 2026, we know that man-induced biodiversity shifts can have major unintended consequences on human societies : see the example given by Ilya, where the eradication of sparrows by Mao led to a 20% decrease in crop yields. Likewise, pesticide use in some places may already be harming yields because of its impacts on pollinators (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6790783/). I'm not saying that it should not be done, just that it should be weighted very carefully, and definitely deserves a mention in such an article
Really enjoyed this. One lesson from the screwworm case is that “not eradicating” does not necessarily mean not intervening: containment requires permanent mass releases, surveillance, and repeated responses to reinvasion. So the relevant comparison is often between eradication and indefinite intervention, not between intervention and nature. And the costs of the status quo include human suffering, economic losses, and potentially enormous and largely invisible suffering among other animals, especially wild animals.
One possibility I have been thinking about for some time is whether *Wolbachia*-based approaches could eventually be extended to the screwworms. The challenge would not only be to establish a stable transinfection and strong cytoplasmic incompatibility, but to ensure that this actually produces sustained population suppression: if the infection reached fixation without reducing reproductive capacity or parasitic behavior, the population could persist. It could be especially interesting to explore combinations involving female sterility, reduced larval survival, or attenuation of parasitic behavior.
This article and the discussion in the comments sparked an important research question for me: how should we balance the potential public-health benefits of suppressing malaria-transmitting mosquitoes against the possible ecological consequences of reducing their populations?
What evidence can help us understand whether the health gains outweigh the ecological risks, and how might that balance vary by mosquito species, intervention, and local ecosystem? It seems like a valuable question for us as public-health practitioners to explore, especially in malaria-endemic settings.
Yes! I’d like to learn how regulators approach this kind of risk-benefit trade-offs. Releasing millions of genetically engineered mosquitoes into environment is quite different from approving a drug that an individual may choose to take.
Entire species routinelly got extincted during all the the evolution. The nature is not static. We need to get rid of this supersticious idolatry of nature.
Not a word for the possible environmental impact of plummeting mosquito populations, an insect which many animals (bats, etc) heavily prey on? Even more so as the Oxitec tech has the potential to make this decline irreversible
I was also looking for this in the article. I have no prior opinions, but are there tradeoffs with regard to reducing the mosquito population? It seems pretty glib to use the "you can just do stuff" framing and not spend a little time with tradeoffs, or if that's not a concern then explain why.
Easy to sit in developed countries and muse about ‘environmental impacts’. If our friends and neighbors were dying of malaria would we be so concerned about hypotheticals and by consequence so indifferent to the plight of millions? Suppose we somehow eradicate mosquitos in a few areas and find that the consequences are unexpectedly disastrous, well we can always let them come back, can’t we? Worldwide eradication, even with a broad consensus and massive funding would take decades—if mosquito eradication leads to bad consequences we’ll be able to see them unfold in slow-motion and change course. Lastly, it’s worth noting that many of these mosquitos are invasive species, and so this effort could be viewed correctly as restoring natural systems to an earlier state.
I could roll with such a plan, with a few extra precautions (think about the consequences of potential horizontal gene transfers, etc). My point was : when you write such an article, show me that you have thought about biodiversity and have a serious plan in this respect
I was also missing a bit of nuance in the article beyond simply implying that faster approval is automatically better. Perhaps the environmental risks are extremely low compared to public health benefits, but they do bring a new kind of uncertainty that should be discussed.
Regulatory caution makes sense given this uncertainty. At the same time, delays cost lives, so it’s troubling if they happen because agencies struggle to decide whether an engineered mosquito is a “drug” or a “pesticide”.
Humans need to stop messing with nature and find natural solutions to the problems we face. I’m no tree hugger, but eradicating an entire species will certainly have devastating downstream ecological consequences. We are not gods and we need to stop acting like we are.
The flip side is how many lives are lost to the diseases carried by mosquitos?
The negative effects are particular severe in poor countries.
I agree, but to not address the likely tradeoffs seems like a bit of an omission in an article by WiP. I enjoy their work and usually find them rigorous and persuasive. There might be good reasons not to worry, or to accept the tradeoffs and deploy the technology for the human health benefits. I just want to see that in the article.
Especially when coupled with the bombastic "Mosquitos Are A Choice" framing! Like ok, maybe!
Caution regarding ecological cascades is warranted, yet treating the status quo as morally neutral ignores millions of preventable deaths. Specific mosquito vectors occupy narrow niches where targeted removal carries low ecological risk.
How do you know it will have devastating downstream consequences? Will they be worse than the consequences of allowing these animals infect and kill many millions of humans every year?
I can't stand the casual misanthropy of the rich, spoiled, "oh the environment" crowd.
https://mattball.substack.com/p/the-continuing-cruelty-of-wealthy
Obviously I'm not saying this because of my sentimentalism and love for mosquitoes. In 2026, we know that man-induced biodiversity shifts can have major unintended consequences on human societies : see the example given by Ilya, where the eradication of sparrows by Mao led to a 20% decrease in crop yields. Likewise, pesticide use in some places may already be harming yields because of its impacts on pollinators (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6790783/). I'm not saying that it should not be done, just that it should be weighted very carefully, and definitely deserves a mention in such an article
Really enjoyed this. One lesson from the screwworm case is that “not eradicating” does not necessarily mean not intervening: containment requires permanent mass releases, surveillance, and repeated responses to reinvasion. So the relevant comparison is often between eradication and indefinite intervention, not between intervention and nature. And the costs of the status quo include human suffering, economic losses, and potentially enormous and largely invisible suffering among other animals, especially wild animals.
One possibility I have been thinking about for some time is whether *Wolbachia*-based approaches could eventually be extended to the screwworms. The challenge would not only be to establish a stable transinfection and strong cytoplasmic incompatibility, but to ensure that this actually produces sustained population suppression: if the infection reached fixation without reducing reproductive capacity or parasitic behavior, the population could persist. It could be especially interesting to explore combinations involving female sterility, reduced larval survival, or attenuation of parasitic behavior.
I can't see what can go wrong!
Let's do sparrows next! (They eat wheat. Hence we will be able to harvest more!!) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Pests_campaign
This article and the discussion in the comments sparked an important research question for me: how should we balance the potential public-health benefits of suppressing malaria-transmitting mosquitoes against the possible ecological consequences of reducing their populations?
What evidence can help us understand whether the health gains outweigh the ecological risks, and how might that balance vary by mosquito species, intervention, and local ecosystem? It seems like a valuable question for us as public-health practitioners to explore, especially in malaria-endemic settings.
Yes! I’d like to learn how regulators approach this kind of risk-benefit trade-offs. Releasing millions of genetically engineered mosquitoes into environment is quite different from approving a drug that an individual may choose to take.
Entire species routinelly got extincted during all the the evolution. The nature is not static. We need to get rid of this supersticious idolatry of nature.
Evaluating the robustness of these conclusions requires accounting for asymmetric tail risks in deployment environments.