The Works in Progress Newsletter

The Works in Progress Newsletter

Sichuan and the Sun Belt

Don’t put all your eggs in one city

Works in Progress's avatar
Works in Progress
Nov 16, 2026

Dan Wang explores why America and China both draw their strength from many rival cities, not one dominant capital.

This is a column: a lighter piece from the Works in Progress extended universe, designed to be enjoyed in print. If you’d like to opt out of columns, or any other section, you can do so here.


Vienna has five times more people than Graz, Austria’s second city. London is four times, Seoul six times, and Paris seven times larger than their countries’ next largest cities. These primate cities are the singular political, cultural, and financial centers of their countries, hosting the overwhelming concentration of the national elite.

Washington, DC and Beijing are awesomely powerful entities. Yet Beijing is not China’s largest city – that’s Shanghai – while DC does not rank among even the top five metro areas of the United States. The political center of both countries sometimes struggles to assert itself against other national hubs. That tension imbues the United States and China with productive friction. It is part of the reason that they are superpowers that have been able to combine social dynamism with jealous states.

Earlier this summer, I visited a few comedy shows in Shanghai. Performers have to submit their scripts beforehand so that censors can expurgate any routine that carries a whiff of political commentary. But they will permit jokes on regional stereotypes. I listened to stand-up comedians make fun of Shanghainese, who worship money while henpecked husbands are governed by formidable women. I heard them say that folks from Liaoning and other northeastern provinces became conniving drunks after the local economy collapsed, but they are redeemed by humor and loyalty. Everyone appreciated the idea that people in the northern metropolis of Beijing can hold forth beautifully on any topic – though that is all they can do.

This comedy reveals a deeper point: China is made up of distinctive macro regions. China’s central government has for millennia tried to impose its will on the entire nation. Though top leader Xi Jinping wields more governance instruments than any former emperor, central authorities still have to contend with the ambitions of different regions. New investments do not end up in Beijing by default. They also go toward the southwestern mountain zone centered around Sichuan and Chongqing, the coastal provinces of Fujian and Guangdong, the populous heartland of Hubei and Hunan, and around a half dozen other macro zones.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from The Works in Progress Newsletter.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 Works in Progress · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.